A name on a succession plan tells you who the company has in mind. Your next question should be specific: what evidence shows that person is ready to take responsibility?
Have they led a difficult operating review? Resolved a disagreement across departments? Delegated a significant assignment and held someone accountable for completing it?
Those questions give you something useful to work on before you need a replacement.
New succession research puts readiness in focus
On November 10, 2026, Wharton Executive Education released research conducted by The Harris Poll. Among 2,544 business leaders at director level and above across seven markets, including the United States, 86% considered succession planning critical. Only 48% said their organization was very prepared for a leadership transition.
The survey was fielded August 4–13, 2025. These are global, self-reported findings released this month, not a new U.S.-only workforce measurement. Read the research announcement and methodology.
For your business, the practical question is whether the people named in your plan have had a fair opportunity to demonstrate the work.
Separate emergency coverage from permanent readiness
Start with one critical role. Ask what would need to keep moving if its current leader became unavailable.
Someone may be able to maintain the schedule, approve routine work and keep customers informed during an absence. That is valuable coverage. Taking permanent responsibility may also require setting priorities, managing a budget and developing other managers.
Record those decisions separately. You can trust someone with temporary coverage while continuing to prepare them for a broader role.
Also ask whether the employee wants the position. Discuss its actual responsibilities, working conditions and expectations. Interest should come from a conversation with the person.
Use the PXT Select Leadership Report to focus the work
PXT Select gives employers information about thinking style, behavioral traits and interests. Its Leadership Report adds insight into an individual's approach to leading.
Wiley organizes the report around six leadership skills: Creating a Vision, Developing Strategies, Ensuring Results, Inspiring People, Being Approachable and Mentoring Others. It includes potential strengths, challenges and suggested interview questions. See Wiley's description of the Leadership Report.
Use that information to choose what to discuss and observe. For example, if the role depends heavily on developing other people, make mentoring and delegation part of the preparation. Ask the employee to explain how they would set expectations, check progress and respond when someone needs help.
The report helps focus that conversation. Completing it does not establish that an employee has already managed a budget, mastered a technical process or delivered a difficult transition. Confirm those requirements through the relevant work and qualifications.
Give the person responsibility with clear boundaries
Choose an assignment that matters to the role and can be supervised appropriately. Examples include leading a department planning meeting, coordinating a cross-functional improvement or taking responsibility for a defined operating review.
Before it starts, agree on five things:
- The outcome. What must be completed, decided or improved?
- The authority. What can the employee decide without asking?
- The limits. What requires escalation, approval or specialist involvement?
- The support. Who is available, and when will they check in?
- The evidence. What work, decisions and feedback will you review?
Keep safety-critical, regulated and technically restricted responsibilities with appropriately qualified people. Development assignments need proper authority and supervision.
Give employees being considered for the same role comparable opportunities to show relevant capability. Document the assignments and the support provided so your review reflects what each person actually had a chance to do.
Review how the result was achieved
A completed assignment is a starting point. Ask how the employee got it done.
Did they involve the right people? Make decisions within their authority? Raise a problem early enough to address it? Give clear direction? Leave the team able to continue the work?
For an employee already leading others, CheckPoint 360° can add structured feedback from people who regularly observe their behavior. Use it to identify development priorities and support follow-through. It is a leadership-development resource, not a stand-alone promotion decision or proof of readiness for an untested responsibility.
Tell participants how feedback will be used and who will have access. Preserve the stated confidentiality arrangements. A development process needs clear expectations from the start.
Make the next decision specific
At the review, record what the evidence supports. Avoid leaving the discussion at “high potential.”
| Readiness statement | What to record |
|---|---|
| Can provide temporary coverage | Responsibilities covered, authority limits and escalation contact. |
| Can own a defined responsibility | Evidence from the assignment and the support still needed. |
| Needs another development opportunity | The specific gap, next assignment, accountable manager and review date. |
| Not pursuing this role | The employee's preference and any development path they want to explore. |
These are working descriptions for your planning discussion, not assessment scores or permanent labels. Explain the decision to the employee. Participation in a development plan should not be presented as a guaranteed promotion.
A useful review ends with an owner and a date. Who will arrange the next assignment? Who will provide support? When will you review the evidence again?
Start with one role and one real assignment
You do not need to finish a company-wide succession program to make progress. Select one role where a vacancy would disrupt the business. Identify interested employees. Review the available evidence. Then give someone a defined opportunity to demonstrate a responsibility they have not yet owned.
The Assessment Company® can help you select and use assessment reports that support that work. PXT Select brings insight into the person and their leadership approach. CheckPoint 360° supports focused development where observers can provide informed feedback.
Have a critical role with no clearly prepared successor? Talk with The Assessment Company® about the role, the people you are developing and the evidence you need next. Call 800-434-2630.

